Creepy “Eyeball” Appetizers

I’ve seen these eyeball appetizers floating (eew) around TikTok. So of course, I’ve been dying to make them.

There are about a zillion versions, mostly with olives for pupils or iris, or both. Let it never be said our creepy community isn’t frighteningly creative!

Fair warning: mine contains dairy and pork. But you can sub non-dairy versions, leave out the pork and throw a few chopped mushrooms in there, or fill your mushroom caps with anything that looks real and tastes good. (This one blew my hair back, but the next batch will need to be low-fat due to health restrictions.)

Whatever you choose, a plate full of eyes is always a hit at Halloween parties. Something about the human eye just freaks people out, at least when it’s not inside a head. Let me know how your own delicious treats came out by dropping a comment below. And stay spooky!